Are Assumptions Creating Unintentional Learning Gaps?
What if the very systems you rely on are unconsciously creating gaps in student learning? The uncomfortable truth is that assumptions—from the district level down to the classroom—foster a lack of clarity that no one intends. Casey uncovers how to spot these unintentional gaps and walks through the essential first step: using simple awareness tools and the Clarity Cycle Framework to bring absolute clarity to expectations, instruction, and student needs.
Check out the Better Data Meetings Tomorrow Course
Your teams are itching for CLARITY! That can be a complex thing to provide. But I have a framework that guides you to do just that– gain and create clarity! www.catchingupwithcasey.com/claritycycleframework
Need help getting your leaders trained in a purposeful way? https://www.catchingupwithcasey.com/identity
Ready to build the habits of a clarity-driven leader? Get The Craft of Clarity book!
Subscribe to my newsletter to get the resources mentioned in podcast episodes! www.catchingupwithcasey.com/newsletter
0:03 Welcome to the Catching Up with Casey show. If you are tired of chasing buy in, frustrated with teams who can't seem to get on the same page, or over the constant struggle of holding people accountable without micromanaging, this is the show for you. I'm Casey Watts, speaker, author, and the creator of the Clarity Cycle Framework. I help leaders just like you take teams from frustration to alignment so teams can work collectively toward a common purpose in a committed way instead of against each other as though they are functioning in different organizations. And we do it all through the craft of clarity. Whether you lead from the middle or you were the front facing leader of your organization on this show, we bring clarity to the seemingly small things in leadership that make the biggest difference because clarity precedes capacity. Now, with all of that said, let's dive into today's episode. Hey, everybody, welcome to a solo episode. Today I am addressing unintentional gaps or talking about how we can address unintentional gaps. And I'm starting with a did you know segment, which I told you guys in the last episode or a couple of episodes ago. That's this is something I wanted to try out. You know, usually, especially if
1:37 I have guests on, we start with tell us something that is just just makes you the average Joe uniquely you and I, and I enjoy that a lot. But I also think it would be really interesting to have a did you know segment. And I'm thinking that this did, you know, could be something that is either personal about someone or it could just be a did you know fact something like did you know we have this book somewhere in this house. I'll have to find it because it would be great to keep up here for this purpose. But and when I say up here, I mean, in my office that is located in my house, my Home Office. So it is titled do Penguins have knees?
2:19 So that's one of them that there's another that has another title, has a squirrel on the cover of it. But really the idea is it's just random facts, things that you may not know that are super interesting or perhaps not interesting. But yeah, so we're starting with a did you know? And today's did you know is personal because it relates to the topic. And a couple of days ago, I posted on LinkedIn a picture of me singing with someone Did you know that my first choice of major was jazz performance? I was determined to become a vocal artist specifically or work in the realm of jazz performance specifically vocally.
3:07 And I do have some background in like piano, guitar, but not not as much as my vocal background. So it made me think about the reason I posted the picture is because it reminded me of this idea of unintentional gaps. And I'm just going to read you the caption for this LinkedIn post. So it's me singing with someone else. And I'll just tell you the background is I I love, love, love supporting artists with harmonies. That's one of my favorite things to do. And so, you know, you as someone who supports a vocalist with harmonies or with overlapping melodies, you have to be really attuned to their habits. The the looks that they give.
3:58 You have to know about you have to match their vocal tone. So anyway, there's a lot of thought that goes into it, but here's what I posted about that. Until you have performed with someone so consistently and intentionally that you can anticipate their next move and they yours, no assumptions can be made. Clarity is essential. Conversations, a shared language, and lots of rehearsal and reflection are absolutely necessary if we want the audience to do more than listen to music, but rather engage with it. And so it is in our schools. I recently posted about unintentional gaps that occur in student learning and posed the question, why? So almost every talk that I give, be it a keynote or I'm working with, I'm doing a presentation for a breakout session at a conference or I'm working with school teams, almost always the idea of unintentional gaps comes up.
4:57 And when I posted about this the first time, and so why? Why are we experiencing unintentional gaps? What are your ideas? Some different people posted some of their thoughts, which completely aligned with my ideas as well. But one of the things that came up was assumptions. The role, the major role that assumptions play in fostering unintentional gaps. And then I go on to say for as long as the world has existed and will exist, no program, product or initiative will close the gaps, especially those that are unintentionally created. For these are merely the instruments utilized by that which matters most, the actual difference makers, and that is your people. So today I want us to talk about assumptions that are made, and I want to, I want to give you 2 very practical things that you can use.
5:48 It's really one thing that you're doing 2 practical ways to do it in order for us to challenge assumptions and thus either close the gaps that already exist or prevent future unintentional gaps from happening. When we look at our organization, specifically schools, and we think about unintentional gaps in student learning, this is typically occurring for a variety of reasons. And it's not. It's not just designated to one group of educators or one group of people in the education system.
6:33 It's dedicated to multiple different groups of people. I want to tell you about those groups and the assumptions that are sometimes made. OK, so district leaders could assume that campus leaders have a grasp on reflective leadership skills, right? Just we, a district leader may see that a campus leader or even a campus leadership team is not coming to them with complaints. It's doing everything that they're told to do is carrying on as per usual. Perhaps they even have relatively decent scores on state assessments or whatever. The data, you know, shows that their their campus is doing well.
7:16 So they make the assumptions that leaders have a really good grasp on leadership skills in order to manage their people. That assumption is not always accurate, despite the scores that we might see for a campus. Then let's move on to campus leaders. What are the assumptions that campus leaders might be making? Campus leaders could assume that teachers have a very clear understanding of the campus goals or a clear understanding of what's expected of them in their classroom instructionally. And they make this assumption because they have told teachers or they set the expectations time and again. And campus leaders may feel like, man, we've been so clear about our expectations and then we make the assumptions that because of that, teachers have a clear understanding. However, what we then notice is that people aren't exactly implementing the things that we've discussed or they're not implementing it to the level or depth to which we've expected them to do.
8:21 OK, so let's go on to teachers. So we've got talked about district leaders, campus leaders, Now teachers. Teachers assume what students do or do not know, or they assume what students can or cannot do. They also sometimes may assume that other teachers approaches are the same as theirs. I will never forget first time I came out of the classroom and moved into an instructional leadership role. I was fascinated by how many different things I saw and I've had these conversations with others as well. Others who claim, well, we were asked to do this.
9:03 So I, I'm I'm remembering a specific case where a campus was wanting to implement guided reading at the time. This was many years ago. So don't come at me with a guided reading. Are you kidding? But they were implementing guided reading many years ago and that that was the goal for the campus. That was what they were focused on. And I, I was meeting with small groups of teachers to discuss this and what it would look like as it was implemented. And a teacher said, I don't understand why we're working on this. We're all doing this. But she was seeing things from a very narrow lens, through her own classroom lens. And what she didn't see what was is what was not happening in other classrooms that was happening in hers. And then too, I, I love what several people said in their comments to one of these LinkedIn posts that I created. I'm, I'm looking at one and, and I love the way this person said this.
10:12 It's Doctor Jones on LinkedIn. She says we can't assume that students know something we haven't even taught yet. We also can't assume that they don't know something that we've taught. And that's the importance of pre assessments. Tammy Mazowski says. What comes to mind for me is when we assume students know what we could, what we would consider as common knowledge or simple things. We can never assume students know or remember routine and pursuit procedures. We cannot assume they know the expectation when they didn't and then fault them for not knowing the instruction. So there are so many different assumptions we can make as teachers in the classroom. And then let's move on to what students might assume because they are part of this as well.
10:59 They are a stakeholder in this. Students may assume that what happens in one classroom must also happen the same in another classroom. And when it doesn't, not only are they having to learn new procedures, routines, and ways of learning from a teacher, they're also having to learn the content. This is when those unintentional gaps start to happen. Obviously, we're not intending for unintentional gaps to happen, but they do all the same. So how do we prevent that? How do we begin to bridge the gaps that already exist and prevent unintentional gaps moving forward?
11:41 You guys know I'm always going to lean into the idea of clarity. We must gain clarity and we must create clarity. But I want to get more granular than that big idea today. And the first granular thing that I can say about it that is probably going to mean that be the most impactful is awareness. Awareness is your first step, but not only do you need to be aware as a leader, but your people have to be aware as well. Your staff has to be aware. You are considering like where and how are assumptions being made on this campus or in this district?
12:22 And then you're reflecting on how leaders and teachers are building collective efficacy or how collective efficacy is being compromised because of the assumptions that are made. So there are two things that I sent out in to my e-mail list yesterday. I would love to provide this to you as well. If you want this resource, be sure to subscribe to the newsletter so you can get access to all the resources that I send. You'll see that in the show notes. So go go click on the link there. Or if you're like, I want it directly to my e-mail, e-mail me at kessiecasey@clarity-driven.com and I will get you these resources.
13:03 But the first is specifically for leaders and the this is the Clarity Cycle Framework rubric. Even if you are not going through the Clarity Cycle Framework, this is a good place that you can begin to start thinking about where could our assumptions be getting in the way and creating unintentional gaps. So this rubric was designed for campuses to evaluate their progress in the six areas of the Clarity Cycle Framework. And it can be really great as a reflection tool to see where, where assumptions have been made by leaders specifically regarding your progress toward like campus improvement plans or when you're implementing, implementing a new initiative. So if you are noticing, man, we we feel like we have communicated the expectations to staff really clearly, but we're not seeing certain things implemented or implemented to the depth or degree that we're expecting. So this is a great tool to reflect on that and see maybe where some assumptions are getting away and where the unintentional gaps are happening. So that's kind of thinking about gaps among adults on your campus, which then filters down to the gaps in student learning. But let's talk about the unintentional gaps and how you can in student learning and how you can address this with staff. I have a slide deck that I also provided in this e-mail that I have personally used with so
14:36 many teacher teams. And it is great at painting a picture of these unintentional gaps, but through the lens of a student, OK, It's so valuable. It sparks enlightening conversations if you're using the right kind of coaching language to promote enlightening conversations. I've found these to be really helpful during vertical alignment meetings. But truly, they can be used anytime. So I want to actually take you through what these slides say and what they look like. And again, if you are eager to take these and utilize them in your own way on your own campus, in your district, or as a presenter, feel free to e-mail me or be sure you sign up for the newsletter. So here's how it goes.
15:27 There's just each slide has a different grade level label and I have grades kinder, first, second, third, 4th, and then it skips over to 6th. These slides are specific to math, I believe. Yes, these slides are specific to math. However, I do have a set that are specific to language arts. I would just have to locate them. Really and truly, you can adjust these based on any concept, any subject area. The Sky's the limit. OK, so here's how it goes. This is from the perspective of a student again, so we're starting with the kindergarten student.
16:11 My kindergarten teacher focused on pictorial models and number sentences. I did not get practice with concrete models and now I have a gap in my conceptual understanding of what addition and subtraction is. Kindergarten moves to 1st grade teacher. My first grade teacher assumed I had practice with concrete and pictorial models in kindergarten and focused on writing number sentences. I can write number sentence as well, but I don't understand how numbers go together or how they can be taken apart. First grade moves to 2nd grade. My second grade teacher knew that I needed to use algorithms in 3rd grade, so she focused her instruction there and not on mental strategies based on place value.
17:01 I do not understand how addition and subtraction are related and I can only add and subtract if I have a piece of paper to write on 2nd to 3rd grade. My third grade teacher wants me to do well on the standardized test and told me to only focus on how to carry the one to regroup. I do not understand why I cross off a number and change it to a nine and then move A1 over when I'm subtracting 4th grade. My 4th grade teacher thought I knew how to regroup a number so she went really fast through subtracting decimals. I don't understand what the decimal means and I'm really confused about how to regroup. And then all the way to 6th grade, I've always heard put the big number on top when subtracting. Now my 6th grade teacher is doing the opposite. I'm so confused.
18:03 So those are the slides that we go through. We, there's a, there's a lot more to these slides like what we're doing before and what we're doing after these slides. I would love to have a conversation with you about that if that's something that you're interested in. But this is just a great example of how our assumptions can get in the way of clarity, how our assumptions can foster those unintentional gaps. So again, if this is something that's interesting to you, you want to see more, join my newsletter. I sent out resources almost weekly. And then if you want these directly in your inbox, just e-mail me and I'll respond.
18:43 Casey at clarity-driven.com. OK, I hope you've enjoyed this conversation. I would love to hear from you. What do you notice gets in the way of clarity in terms of how it's a lack of it is fostering unintentional gaps? OK guys, I hope you have a wonderful weekend. And that's it. We'll see you in the next episode. Bye. Hey listener, I am so honored that you listen to today's episode and I hope you gained something valuable from it. I'd also be honored if you did ME3 solid favors. First, subscribe to this show. I've got a lot of great content coming up, and I don't want you to miss any of it.
19:29 Second, be sure you're following me on social media platforms. You can find me at. Catch up with Casey on LinkedIn or Instagram. And finally, if you were looking to book a dynamic and relatable speaker for your next event, conference, or retreat, I would love to bring a message about how the crash of clarity makes a significant impact on both leadership and life.
RSS Feed